Who else was involved in the evolution debate?
Posted on March 1st, 2009 by Intute staff
In this year of Darwin celebrations we thought it might be fun to look a bit more closely at some of the other major players in the debate in the years immediately after the presentation of the theory of evolution through natural selection.
According to the Linnean Society website, the meeting in 1858 at which the Darwin and Wallace papers were first presented was something of a non-event: neither of the authors was present and the papers were read by the Secretary of the Society at the end of a long session. To quote the Linnean Society website “It is doubtful that many in the audience were able to take in the full import of the message they contained”.
However, in subsequent months, years and now centuries, the debate initiated by the ideas which Darwin and Wallace had formulated independently of each other has continued, often acrimoniously. Richard Owen, a brilliant comparative anatomist famous for naming the dinosaurs, was one of the most outspoken early opponents of the idea of evolution through natural selection whilst another eminent scientist, Thomas Henry Huxley, famously argued in its favour at the 1860 meeting of the British Association.
Below is a small selection of websites catalogued in Intute which put the evolution debate into a historical context and give some biographical information about the major protagonists.
General historical context
Linnean Society of London
Website of the Linnean Society, London. The society was founded in 1788 with the aim of the cultivation of the science of natural history in all its branches. Today the society encourages debate, research and publications in natural history and maintains its historical collections. The site provides information about the society’s activities and publications, including its series of journals and symposia. There is also a Web publications section which contains online publications relating to the history and science of the Linnean Society. There is information about the library and its collections, which include taxonomy, systematics, flora and fauna, as well as evolution and the history of biology. Additionally, there are short biographies of Carl Linnaeus, Darwin and Wallace, and Sir James Edward Smith and details of Project Linnaeus which seeks to make available in electronic format the entire correspondence of Carl Linnaeus. The site also provides links to the Society’s online collections of specimens and manuscripts as well as to its Library catalogue.
http:/www.linnean.org/
A history of evolutionary thought
From UCMP (University of California Museum of Paleontology), this website offers biographic information on the people who have influenced our current understanding of evolutionary theory. Information is divided into several chronological categories: ‘founders of natural science’, ‘great naturalists of the 18th century’, ‘preludes to evolution’, ‘natural selection’ and ‘the modern synthesis’. Several significant scientists are profiled in each section, these include Aristotle, Leonardo da Vinci, Carolus Linnaeus, Jean-Baptiste Lamarck, Mary Anning and Sir Richard Owen.
http:/www.ucmp.berkeley.edu/history/evothought.html
Natural history biographies
The Natural History Museum (London) has provided this Web page providing biographies of nine naturalists: Charles Darwin, Alfred Russel Wallace, Sir Hans Sloane, Joseph Banks, Richard Owen, Samuel Wilberforce, Thomas Huxley, William MacGillivray and Joseph Wolf. As well as the work of the naturalist, each biography is accompanied by a relevant timeline.
http:/www.nhm.ac.uk/nature-online/science-of-natural-history/biographies/i
Voyages of discovery / Natural History Museum (London)
Based on an exhibition at The Natural History Museum in London, this site explores the voyages of several pioneers in scientific expeditions, whose travels had a major impact on the science and culture of the societies they came from. Presented in a clear and entertaining manner, the site includes, for each voyage: a short profile of the explorer, a sketch map of the route travelled and examples of specimens collected and illustrations made. The explorers or naturalists covered include Darwin, Sloane, Wallace and Murray. A special section on Captain Cook’s first voyage provides a more in-depth text, with still illustrations and graphics.
http:/www.nhm.ac.uk/nature-online/science-of-natural-history/expeditions-c
Alfred Russel Wallace
Alfred Russel Wallace page
This extensive and well presented site contains information relating to Alfred Russel Wallace (1823-1913), the English naturalist, evolutionist and social critic. Resources available include a chronology of the main events in Wallace’s life, quotes from his writings, an extensive bibliography of his publications and a selected bibliography of writings about Wallace. Some of Wallace’s publications and transcripts from interviews are presented in full-text. There is also a news section and an FAQ. The site is maintained by Dr Charles H Smith, who can be contacted by email.
http:/www.wku.edu/~smithch/index1.htm
Wallace collection
Part of the website of the Natural History Museum, the Wallace Collection brings together a selection of digitised letters, notes, articles and some of the insect specimens which Alfred Russel Wallace collected on his travels. The introduction gives information about the whole collection of Wallace’s papers held in the Library of the NHM, and about Wallace’s contribution to understanding natural selection. Further sections go into greater detail about various aspects of Wallace’s life and work, and there is a search facility.
http:/www.nhm.ac.uk/nature-online/collections-at-the-museum/wallace-collec
On the law that has regulated the introduction of new species by Alfred Russel Wallace
The website of ‘Human nature review’ hosts an online version of the above paper written in 1855 by Alfred Russel Wallace. This law, often referred to as the Sarawack Law, looks at geographical and geological distributions of plants and animals, and the divergence of species. This essay is posted on a Web page that offers access to related works by other theorists, including Charles Darwin.
http:/www.human-nature.com/darwin/archive/wallace.html
On the tendency of varieties to depart indefinitely from the original type by Alfred Russel Wallace
Presented on the website of Human Nature Review, this is an essay written by Alfred Russel Wallace at Ternate, Indonesia in 1858. The essay introduces the concept of natural selection and was sent by the author to Charles Darwin, who himself had similar ideas on this subject. This site also hosts other works by both Wallace and Darwin.
http:/www.human-nature.com/darwin/archive/arwallace.html
Richard Owen
Dinosaur history
This resource introduces you to the people that contributed to the study and knowledge of dinosaurs throughout history. The accounts begin around 750 BC with Xenophanes who first recognised the existence of fossils, and proceeds through the centuries to 1899. Subsequent years have yet to be completed (as of August 2004). Other famous names featured in the history include Georges Cuvier, William Buckland and Richard Owen. These pages have been created by Professor John Chamberlain of Brooklyn College, City University of New York.
http:/academic.brooklyn.cuny.edu/geology/chamber/dinohist1.html
Paper dinosaurs, 1824 – 1969
The electronic catalogue of an exhibition on the history of dinosaur discovery, through some of the most significant printed materials published from 1824 to 1969, and including the original publications of Gideon Mantell, Richard Owen and Othniel Marsh among others. It provides a visual tour of over 150 illustrations of dinosaurs from papers presented at the exhibition. These quality images are accompanied by text descriptions and can be zoomed to full size whilst maintaining high resolution. The exhibition was presented by Linda Hall Library of science, engineering and technology in Kansas City, United States, and the online version was redesigned in 2009.
http:/www.lindahall.org/events_exhib/exhibit/exhibits/dino/
Thomas Henry Huxley
Thomas Henry Huxley (1825-1895)
This Web page presents a brief biography of Thomas Henry Huxley and his scientific thoughts. He was a strong supporter of Darwin’s theory of evolution in addition to being an eminent scientist himself. His main subjects of study were palaeontology and zoology. This essay is hosted on the website of the Museum of Paleontology at the University of California, Berkeley.
http:/www.ucmp.berkeley.edu/history/thuxley.html
Huxley file
This extensive website is dedicated to the life and work of Victorian biologist Thomas Henry Huxley (1825-1895), who is best known today for his support of Charles Darwin’s theory of evolution by natural selection. Resources available include; 680 pieces of published and unpublished text by Huxley; 148 pictures by and on him, with an uncounted number of pictures in text by and for him; and 120 commentaries on him. Huxley wrote on many topics including education, anthropology, philosophy, religion, social studies and style, as well as his works as a professional biologist. Indexes are provided for published texts, letters, commentaries on Huxley and illustrations by or relating to him. Some index entries are linked to the full-text of the item or the relevant images. In addition there are 21 guides to information on important subjects which Huxley dealt with, an extensive bibliography, a timeline of events in his life and a family tree. The layout of the site includes colour codings to identify different resource types. The site is an excellent starting point for researchers interested in Huxley and his life and work.
http:/aleph0.clarku.edu/huxley/
Rise and progress of palaeontology by Thomas Henry Huxley
This is an online version of The Rise and Progress of Palaeontology by Thomas Henry Huxley. Huxley was an eminent 19th century zoologist and palaeontologist, and a supporter of Charles Darwin’s theory of evolution. The essay discusses what fossils are and what they represent, and the emergence of palaeontology as a science. This text has been made available by Project Gutenberg, a producer of electronic books. It is requested that the user read the copyright and the conditions on the use of the text.
http:/www.gutenberg.org/dirs/etext01/2saht10.txt
Darwiniana / collection of essays by T. H. Huxley
As part of ‘The Huxley File’ created by Charles Blinderman and David Joyce, this section provides access to Huxley’s essays on the publication of ‘The Origin of Species’ by Charles Darwin. The essays also discuss the subsequent debate on evolution.
http:/aleph0.clarku.edu/huxley/CE2/index.html






